The Cohen Commission Report into declines in the Fraser River sockeye runs has been released.
Here is the news release: http://www.cohencommission.ca/en/NewsReleases/FinalReportReleased.php.
And this statement from it: 'Cohen emphasized that the Department of Fisheries and Oceans (DFO)
should fully implement and fund both the 2005 Wild Salmon Policy and
the1986 Habitat Policy. “DFO should develop and publish a detailed
as set out in the Wild Salmon Policy and, without further delay, honour
its commitment to implementation,” he noted. “The goals of the Habitat
Policy and its No Net Loss principle are sound and should be retained.”'
This is a sound recommendation. Anyone who follows salmon issues knows that the Wild Salmon Policy disappeared from view almost immediately after it was written. And the Habitat Policy also contains good information on protecting salmon habitat. It also died an early death. On both issues, DFO has failed badly.
In addition, the Harper government recently gutted the Fisheries Act, the Environmental Protection Act of fish protection as well as began cutting 200 scientists in 2012.
And this statement about fish farms, in the news release preceding the report, states the issue directly and correctly:
'To address the potential conflict for DFO between promoting salmon
farms and regulating them, the Commissioner recommended that DFO no
longer be responsible for promoting salmon farming as an industry and
farmed salmon as a product. “As long as DFO has a mandate to promote
salmon farming, there is a risk that it will act in a manner that
favours the interests of the salmon farming industry over the health of
wild fish stocks,” he said.
The Commissioner concluded that salmon farms along the sockeye migration route
in the Discovery Islands have the potential to introduce exotic
diseases and to aggravate endemic diseases which can have a negative
impact on Fraser River sockeye. “Mitigation measures should not be
delayed in the absence of scientific certainty,” he said.
For that reason, Cohen recommended a freeze on net-pen salmon farm
production in the Discovery Islands until September 30, 2020. “If by
that date, DFO cannot confidently say the risk of serious harm to wild
stocks is minimal, it should then prohibit all net-pen salmon farms from
operating in the Discovery Islands,” he said. Cohen also recommended
that if before September 30, 2020, the government determines that salmon
farms pose more than a minimal risk to Fraser River sockeye, the
government prohibit their operation immediately.'
Here is the report: http://www.cohencommission.ca/en/. Click on the icon and read the 1200 pages of the three volume report. The third volume contains more than 75 recommendations.
Wednesday, 31 October 2012
Friday, 5 October 2012
Salmon Farm Activist Acquitted of Defamation
My guess is the average sport fisher does not know who Don Staniford is. And I venture that Staniford doesn’t know the difference between a bull head and a bull trout, or even how to catch a salmon. But the roughly 300,000 licenced sport fishers in BC owe him their gratitude. That is because he has been fearless in his opposition to in-ocean fish farms, particularly in BC, Scotland, Norway and other countries.
Staniford’s approach to criticizing the industry that has in recent months had well-reported disease problems in BC, Washington, Nova Scotia and Newfoundland, is flamboyant in the extreme and often foolhardy. His approach lies somewhere between Monty Python and Darth Vader, with the Energizer Bunny supplying manic energy to his 24-hour a day activism.
Mainstream Canada sued him for defamation in February 2012. Judge Adair has just released her findings. I have excised five pages of relevant clauses from her ruling and you may find it on my blog, www.fishfarmnews.blogspot.com, which also contains the link to her 71 page ruling – really worth reading in its entirety. [Note: the excised comments are the next post on this blog].
Mainstream’s reasons are summarized in clause 10: “Mainstream claims that, in their natural and ordinary meaning, Mr. Staniford’s statements, in context, meant and were understood to mean that Mainstream’s business and products kill people, and that Mainstream is knowingly marketing a carcinogenic product that causes illness, death and harm. Mainstream says that the “sting” arising from Mr. Staniford’s publications is that farmed salmon – like smoking – causes cancer, and that the salmon farming industry is as odious and dishonest as the tobacco industry.”
Pretty damning stuff. And Judge Adair roasts Staniford’s character: “[his] value judgments… [are] prejudiced, exaggerated and obstinate .” And, [from 174]: “Mr. Staniford’s judgements have no balance because balance does not exist in Mr. Staniford’s world when it comes to salmon farming. He has dedicated himself to eradicating it.” She also found that his comments were defamatory , and that they applied to Mainstream .
But at the end, Adair excused Staniford of defamation on the grounds that he believed what he was saying was true. Having read a lot of what he has written, I ignore his inflammatory approach and follow-up his links to the science. They are on the money.
My opinion is that, sadly, the top four problems for ten species of salmonids are: fish farms, DFO, run of river power and Global Warming. The last we can do little about quickly, but the other three can be addressed today with policy decisions. The Cohen Commission into Fraser sockeye collapse reconvened in December 2011 to assess whether fish farm diseases kill wild salmon. Its report is due by October 30, 2012. I’ll let you know what it says.
Sport fishers should pat Staniford on the back – he has withstood being sued three times over the past decade by fish farms, though never successfully – because his bottom line is to stand with wild salmon in BC. In fairness, I don’t see that fish farms need to be eradicated - they need to be on land where their density-related disease amplification affects no other fish or species. I have found more than 8,000 actual on-land farms around the world, so there is no technological or economic impediment. We need wild salmon and so do 37 species of our wild animals like bears and eagles.